Apple bans a magazine app because “it’s just about Android”

November 30, 2010

Misc. News

Apple is wielding its mighty banhammer again. This time it’s a Danish magazine publisher, Mediaprovider, and its little magazine app all about Android phones and operating systems.

Brian Dixen, the managing director for Mediaprovider, received a call from Apple last week informing him that there was a problem with one of the apps they had submitted. “‘So what’s the problem?’ I asked sheepishly,” says Dixen. The Apple employee, identified as Richard, replied, “You know… your magazine… it’s just about Android…. we can’t have that in our App Store.”

Dixen is not surprised by the ban, but does feel Apple has overstepped its bounds. The approval process is a source of a lot of frustration. “We have to get not only our apps but every single copy of our magazines approved and I wonder what will happen if we choose to make the next issue of our magazine about mobile phones in general a theme issue about Android,” he told MediaWatch.

Danish publishers have had run ins with Apple in the past. Earlier this year, Danish tabloid Ekstra Bladet had their app rejected because of the inclusion of the ‘Page Nine Girl’. Other magazines that Mediaprovider publishes include a gear and gadget magazine, as well as an iPhone magazine.

This story is a bit odd, unless there’s some other reason behind the ban. But if the only reason you’re banning the app is because of its focus on a competing product, then where do you stop? Searching the iTunes App store, I found an app called “BlackBerry Hacks” which is presumably “just about” BlackBerry. Based on this logic, it should be pulled from the store too. I think Apple needs to review this one again.

Article Via Gizmodo
Photo Credit: kodomut

About Eugene Huo

Eugene Huo is a Juno Award winning recording engineer, video editor, photographer, and all around Mac geek. His first Mac experience was with the Macintosh Plus. You never forget your first. You can follow him on twitter @yougenius73, and check out his video game tumblr at yougenius.me.

View all posts by Eugene Huo
Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

It's up to the store owner what gets stocked in their store, whether it's a digital store or real world this has always been the case. It may seem a bit backwards but I can't say it bothers me much, maybe the devs should have read the terms they were agreeing to first?

I'm not sure how as an iOS user, I could support this.

If you don't care about android, don't DL it. But if you do at least you had the choice.

This is an example of Apple sometimes takes advantage of the exclusivity of the App Store, and uses it in anti-competitive ways.

It could of been about cars, boats, a cereal brand, but the fact that its android it was banned? Does my ISP have the right to block competing companies websites from me? I don't think so. Why does Apple have the right to block apps from me?

100% agree. I'm an iOS user and it pisses me off too.

Hmm "metadata"…

3.1 Apps with metadata that mentions the name of any other mobile platform will be rejected.

Isn't it stated in the terms and conditions that you can not name competitors? The last time
I checked this was the case.