During the fourth quarter earnings call this past Monday, Jobs put forward a number of strong statements that were highly critical of a number of Apple’s competitors. Yesterday, a number of those competitors fired back, refuting Jobs’ comments and offering a different opinion. Here’s a summary of the backlash.
Google VP responds in code
Jobs criticized Google’s claim to openness on the call, suggesting that Apple’s “closed” system is the better approach. Andy Rubin, vice president of engineering at Google, and the “father” of Android, posted the following on Twitter:
the definition of open: ‘mkdir android ; cd android ; repo init -u git://android.git.kernel.org/platform/manifest.git ; repo sync ; make’.
A small caveat to this response is that it came from a new and as of yet unverified Twitter account. If Rubin’s post is G[r]eek to you, essentially he provided the code for a Linux machine to compile Android, demonstrating that Android is accessible to anyone.
TweetDeck CEO: fragmentations is not an issue
Jobs pointed out that the Android model results in fragmentation due to the multiple devices and software versions available, which he suggested was a challenge to developers, pointing specifically to TweetDeck.
The CEO of TweetDeck, Iain Dodsworth, denied that this was an issue over Twitter: “Did we at any point say it was a nightmare developing on Android? Errr nope, no we didn’t. It wasn’t.” He also later commented: ” We only have 2 guys developing on Android TweetDeck so that shows how small an issue fragmentation is.” Looks like Jobs may have overstepped just a little bit on that point.
Like a gentleman, Dodsworth did not bring up the fact that Jobs’ didn’t even get the name of the application correct, referring to it as TwitterDeck.
RIM wants people to think for themselves
Jobs took two jabs at RIM. First, he stated that 7-inch screens are too small for tablets – RIM’s upcoming tablet, the PlayBook, will have a 7-inch screen. Jobs also provided some stats that indicated the iPhone had surpassed the Blackberry in the smartphone department, selling 14.2 millions iPhones to RIM’s 12.1 million blackberries.
Jim Balsillie, co-CEO of RIM, disagreed with Jobs, asserting that 7-inch tablets will be a part of the tablet market, and then he took the offensive, criticizing Apple’s decision not to support Adobe Flash:
For those of us who live outside of Apple’s distortion field, we know that 7-inch tablets will actually be a big portion of the market and we know that Adobe Flash support actually matters to customers who want a real web experience,” Balsillie said in his response. “We also know that while Apple’s attempt to control the ecosystem and maintain a closed platform may be good for Apple, developers want more options and customers want to fully access the overwhelming majority of web sites that use Flash.
He also indicated that Apple is leading its customers by the nose, and that customers are “getting tired of being told what to think by Apple.”
In terms of Apple’s iPhone outselling RIM’s blackberry, Balsillie criticized the stats that Jobs provided:
RIM has achieved record shipments for five consecutive quarters and recently shared guidance of 13.8 (million to) 14.4 million BlackBerry smartphones for the current quarter,” Balsillie said. “Apple’s preference to compare its September-ending quarter with RIM’s August-ending quarter doesn’t tell the whole story because it doesn’t take into account that industry demand in September is typically stronger than summer months, nor does it explain why Apple only shipped 8.4 million devices in its prior quarter and whether Apple’s Q4 results were padded by unfulfilled Q3 customer demand and channel orders.
Again, Balsillie took an opportunity to fight back, going on to state: “As usual, whether the subject is antennas, Flash or shipments, there is more to the story and sooner or later, even people inside the distortion field will begin to resent being told half a story.”
A few thoughts
At the end of the day, even though the back and forth is not necessarily the most friendly, I think its great to see these conversations going on. Both Apple and Android’s approaches have merits and limitations, and pander to slightly different audiences. Choice is never a bad thing, nor are discussions about how to do things better. But that being said, Jim Basillie’s known to have his own reality distortion field (see the NHL debacle), and who doesn’t look at this graph, provided by TweetDeck, and think “what a mess.” Pot, meet Kettle.
Article Via AppleInsider
Photo Credit: SaddoBoxing.com














FLICKR
YOUTUBE
RSS
October 20, 2010
0 Comments