Paper reads faster than e-readers, but the iPad is the best option

Paper reads faster than e readers, but the iPad is the best option

While paper still reads faster than any e-book on the market, by at least 6.2 percent, it seems like people are enjoying iPads and Kindles more than they’re enjoying books these days.

During the first part of a Nielsen Norman study, they found that the iPad read 6.2 percent slower than a traditionally printed book. The iPad’s number one competitor, the Kindle, was even slower than an iPad, coming in at 10.2 percent slower. What’s it mean? If you’re planning on cramming for an exam or barreling through your favourite Emily Bronte novel, you’re probably going to need a paper version of the text you’re reading—you’ll save a lot of time.

While there’s no mention of what exactly is slowing down the read, it’s being speculated that display quality and font availability are playing a role in slowing down reading speeds.

But, it’s not all doom and gloom for e-reading devices. In a weird twist, both the Kindle, and the iPad scored higher than traditional books on an “enjoyability scale.” We’re not exactly sure how you can enjoy the written word more on one device over another, all things being equal, but the iPad ranked 5.8, the Kindle 5.7, and books came in at 5.6 on the Nielsen Norman scale.

It almost makes the whole study laughable — “I enjoy this ‘the’ on the iPad a little bit more than that ‘the’ in the book over there.”  Maybe people just have an affinity to Palatino. Who knows.

Keep in mind that the study focused on the e-reader aspects of the device, and had nothing to do with other applications or features.

Article Via Electronista

Photo  Credit: David Bisset

PS.  We love the iPad.  As evidenced by these photos of contributors Simon Wicks and Susan Pigott

Paper reads faster than e readers, but the iPad is the best option

Paper reads faster than e readers, but the iPad is the best option


We're testing out a new service called Spread.Us. Help us share our stories!

About Joshua Schnell

Man, Myth, and Legend, Joshua is the Editor-In-Chief, and founder of Macgasm. He produces two podcasts, Macgasm TV, and The AppOrchard, and can be heard on CBC Radio once every couple of years.

View all posts by Joshua Schnell
Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

I have both a Kindle 2 and and iPad, and I have to say I enjoy the reading experience on my iPad much more for several reasons. First, I like the backlit screen, even though naysayers said that the Kindle was better because of its e-paper technology. In all honesty, I hate having to use a book light to read my Kindle at night in bed, and I've not noticed any eye fatigue with the iPad. Second, I like the page swipe technology better than the mechanical "clicker" on the Kindle. The page swipe is more natural (though, admittedly I accidentally hit the page sometimes and turn it when I don't mean to). On the Kindle, every time you turn a page, you notice it--the slight delay with the e-ink is noticeable, and the click is audible and annoying (especially when your husband is reading his Kindle when you're trying to go to sleep and you hear a "click-a" every few seconds. Third, the Kindle is butt-ugly (even the newer version) and trying to highlight anything or add notes is a pain. The keyboard is horrible, and the mechanism to highlight or choose words is cumbersome. I much prefer the finger-based UI of the iPad. I can really get lost in a book on the iPad, and though I could on the Kindle, too, the iPad UI is much less intrusive. Now I read all my ebooks on my iPad and I'm planning to sell my Kindle.

I haven't had much hands on time with the Kindle 2, and I'll be excited to see how the new Kindle DX plays out in the next couple of month.

Trackbacks

  1. [...] Paper reads faster than e-readers, but the iPad is the best optionMacgasm (blog)E-Reader Market Heats UpNY1Houston Chronicle -tuaw.com (blog) -Delmarva Nowall 82 news articles » [...]

  2. [...] the original post: Paper reads faster than e-readers, but the iPad is the best option – Macgasm (blog) Posted in Ipad | Tags: books-compared, both-slower, cnn, Ipad, kindle, magazine, news-articles, [...]