Comments on: One week in bed with the MBP.

By: macgasm

macgasm — Fri, 31 Oct 2008 03:27:29 +0000

I wonder how accurate these polls are. If they are legitimate votes it raises some good questions. But, I'd like to take them with a grain of salt. I vote for polls that I know nothing about all the time… just so I can see the results. I have a 20 inch Apple Cinema Display that obviously has a matte finish, as well as a 20 inch HP display that has a glossy finish. Movies look a hell of a lot better on the glossy one, but designing stuff in photoshop on that one can be a pain. While I agree that Apple is dumb for removing our options, I don't really see a big enough difference to complain about the lack of matte finish.

I wonder how many of these “voters” have actually used both a glossy screen and a matte screen side by side. My guess, not many…

By: macgasm

macgasm — Fri, 31 Oct 2008 03:27:06 +0000

I wonder how many of these “voters” have actually used both a glossy screen and a matte screen side by side. My guess, not many…

By: R

Fri, 31 Oct 2008 03:08:20 +0000

I DID GO TO A STORE, and checked out the new MacBook Pro's and the reflections were INTOLERABLE.

People who say reflections are a non-issue, must realise that this is a personal thing. It affects some people's eyes more than others. So don't call it bullshit.

Do a google search for "glossy matte poll", and you'll find dozens of polls on the subject.

Here's a review of some results (who prefer matte):

45%
48%
68%
50%
54%
72%

Average: 56%. That's a majority. Actually, it ties in what what the local Apple store salesman told me, which is that it's roughly 50-50 of people who prefer matte and gloss.

Here are some poll questions:

1) What are your feelings on the glossy-only screen in the new MacBook Pro (and MacBook)?

Love it, already ordered one! 5.73%
Looks sharp, planning on buying 15.92%
Looks good, but no plans to purchase 16.97%
Need to see it in person before judging 14.75%
Dislike glossy screen, but will buy anyway 15.06%
Hate glossy screens, will not buy because of it 29.41%
Other? 2.15%

http://www.macosxhints.com/polls/index.php

2) Gloss or Matte?
Gloss - 50.00%
Matte! - 48.39%

http://digital-photography-school.com/forum/sho...

3) Glossy or Matte?
Glossy 24.14%
Matte 68.97%
Neutral (Doesn't Matter) 6.90%
You Can Choose? 0%

http://forums.macrumors.com/showthread.php?t=24...

4) Glossy or Matte Display ? (new imac vs old imac)
Matte 50.00%
Glossy 50.00%

5) What's your display like?

Poll Options:
My matte is great 54.10%
My matte is bad 3.28%
My glossy is great 39.34%
My glossy is bad 3.28%

http://forums.macnn.com/69/mac-notebooks/318569...

6) Glossy or Matte screen?
Glossy 27.27%
Matte 72.73%

http://www.cableforum.co.uk/board/19/33640023-m...